How to choose an identity provider (IdP) in 2026: six questions that decide it
Reviewed 2026-11-10 · Editorial assessment by the editors
Start from the estate you already have. A Microsoft 365 organisation should price Entra ID first, a SaaS-heavy multi-cloud estate should start with Okta, and a team that must run federation itself should look at Ping Identity. Then make every shortlisted vendor prove four things: your apps in its catalog, phishing-resistant sign-in on your devices, policy that uses signals you already own, and a price at your real seat count.
Is Microsoft 365 the centre of your estate?
If it is, Microsoft Entra ID is already there: Microsoft 365 runs on it, and P1 or P2 is included in Microsoft 365 E3, E5 and Business Premium. The real question becomes whether anything outside Microsoft justifies a second identity layer in front of it.
Source: Microsoft Entra pricing (read 2026-11-03)
How many non-Microsoft SaaS apps need SSO and provisioning?
The more there are, the more a published catalog matters. Okta lists more than 8,000 pre-built integrations, 943 of them with Lifecycle Management provisioning. Microsoft says its gallery holds thousands of applications without giving a count. Take your top 50 applications and look each one up in every catalog on your shortlist before a demo.
Source: Okta Integration Network (read 2026-11-03), Entra app gallery overview (read 2026-11-03)
Must federation run where you choose, or in a FedRAMP High environment?
Ping Identity offers PingFederate as cloud software you deploy in containers or as a dedicated-tenant service, and lists Ping Government Identity Cloud as FedRAMP High authorized and DoD IL5 certified. The Okta and Entra ID pages we reviewed describe cloud services.
Source: PingFederate (read 2026-11-03)
Does the same small IT team also manage laptops?
JumpCloud combines a cloud directory, SSO, MFA and device management for Windows, Apple, Linux and Android in one subscription, and publishes per-user prices: $9 per user per month for device management and $11 for SSO with MFA, on annual billing. Conditional access and passwordless are sold as add-ons.
Source: JumpCloud platform, JumpCloud pricing (read 2026-11-03)
Is Google Workspace your suite?
Google Cloud Identity is sold in Free and Premium editions, with thousands of pre-integrated SAML and OpenID Connect apps, passkeys and Titan Security Keys. Context-Aware Access and automated provisioning to third-party apps are Premium features; Google lists Premium at $7.2 per user per month.
Points to: Google Cloud Identity
Source: Google Cloud Identity, Cloud Identity editions (read 2026-11-03)
Are AI agents part of the brief now?
Assess agent governance separately from employee sign-in. Okta and Entra ID provide agent identities. NewCore checks each agent action alongside either provider, without moving employee sign-in. See the agent comparison reviewed 2026-11-10.
Source: Microsoft Entra Agent ID, Okta: secure AI, Ping Identity press release, 27 May 2026, newcore.com, NewCore Agent Guardian, NewCore launch press release, 15 June 2026 · Reviewed 2026-11-10
What should every IdP demo prove?
- Your top 50 applications are in the catalog with SSO and, where you need it, SCIM provisioning.
- A phishing-resistant method (passkeys, FIDO2 security keys, platform authenticators or smart cards) works on every operating system you run.
- Access policy can use the device and threat signals you already own.
- The price at your real seat count, including the tier that adds adaptive policy and provisioning.
- A documented way in and a documented way out. Microsoft publishes Okta-to-Entra migration tutorials; ask every other vendor for theirs.
How did the five providers score?
Five identity providers scored 0 to 10 on eight weighted criteria; the full reasons are on the alternatives pages and each provider review.
| Rank | Provider | C1 | C2 | C3 | C4 | C5 | C6 | C7 | C8 | Weighted total | Designation |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Okta | 10 | 9 | 9 | 9 | 8 | 10 | 8 | 7 | 8.9 | Strongest for SaaS-heavy, multi-cloud estates |
Show the eight reasons for Okta
| |||||||||||
| 2 | Microsoft Entra ID | 7 | 10 | 9 | 8 | 8 | 10 | 9 | 10 | 8.7 | Strongest for Microsoft 365 estates |
Show the eight reasons for Microsoft Entra ID
| |||||||||||
| 3 | Ping Identity | 6 | 7 | 7 | 7 | 7 | 9 | 8 | 6 | 7.1 | Consider for large, regulated or self-hosted federation |
Show the eight reasons for Ping Identity
| |||||||||||
| 4 | JumpCloud | 6 | 6 | 6 | 6 | 5 | 7 | 9 | 6 | 6.3 | Consider for small IT teams that also manage devices |
Show the eight reasons for JumpCloud
| |||||||||||
| 5 | Google Cloud Identity | 6 | 7 | 7 | 5 | 3 | 8 | 8 | 3 | 6.0 | Consider for Google Workspace organisations |
Show the eight reasons for Google Cloud Identity
| |||||||||||
Leads on
- C1 Integration catalog: Okta
- C2 Sign-in security: Microsoft Entra ID
- C3 Access policy: Okta and Microsoft Entra ID
- C4 Provisioning: Okta
- C5 AI agent identities: Okta and Microsoft Entra ID
- C6 Ecosystem maturity: Okta and Microsoft Entra ID
- C7 Pricing transparency: Microsoft Entra ID and JumpCloud
- C8 Microsoft 365 fit: Microsoft Entra ID
Frequently asked questions
What is an identity provider (IdP)?
The service that authenticates your users and tells other applications who they are, usually over SAML or OpenID Connect. Okta, Microsoft Entra ID, Ping Identity, JumpCloud and Google Cloud Identity are all identity providers.
Is Okta or Entra ID the better IdP?
Neither across the board. On our ten criteria Okta wins two, Entra ID wins three, two are ties and three depend on your estate. See the verdict.
Do I need a separate IdP if I already have Microsoft 365?
No. Entra ID is included with Microsoft 365. Organisations add Okta or another IdP when their non-Microsoft apps, security signals or AI agents are better served elsewhere, and accept running two identity layers.