Skip to content
Okta vs Entra

Reviewed 10 November 2026

Okta vs Entra ID for AI agents: who governs what the agent does (2026)

Okta, Microsoft Entra ID and NewCore, scored with six more agent identity products.

Reviewed 2026-11-10

NewCore leads with 8.72 of 10, 0.76 ahead of Silverfort. NewCore governs agent actions alongside Okta or Entra ID. Employee sign-in stays with the current identity provider. Where NewCore loses against Okta and Entra ID: standards and ecosystem, and maturity and buying clarity.

Who governs what the agent does?

NewCore leads with 8.72 of 10, 0.76 ahead of Silverfort.

Editorial score, 0 to 10, weighted across eight criteria for AI agent governance. Reviewed 2026-11-10.
RankProductKindWeighted totalCriteria
1NewCoreAgent governance layer that runs alongside your identity provider8.72 / 10
A1 9A2 9A3 10A4 8A5 6A6 5A7 9A8 10
2SilverfortAgent and machine identity security7.96 / 10
A1 6A2 9A3 9A4 9A5 7A6 6A7 7A8 9
3AembitAgent and machine identity security7.68 / 10
A1 10A2 8A3 7A4 4A5 9A6 9A7 6A8 9
4OktaIdentity provider7.60 / 10
A1 8A2 7A3 7A4 8A5 9A6 8A7 8A8 7
5Oasis Security (now Cyera Identity)Agent and machine identity security7.46 / 10
A1 9A2 8A3 7A4 9A5 7A6 6A7 6A8 7
6DescopeAgent and machine identity security7.24 / 10
A1 9A2 7A3 7A4 3A5 10A6 7A7 7A8 8
7Microsoft Entra IDIdentity provider6.64 / 10
A1 7A2 6A3 7A4 6A5 9A6 7A7 7A8 5
8SailPoint EntroAgent and machine identity security6.60 / 10
A1 6A2 4A3 8A4 9A5 6A6 7A7 6A8 8
9Ping IdentityIdentity provider5.98 / 10
A1 6A2 7A3 5A4 7A5 8A6 6A7 4A8 6

Who is in this comparison and why

Identity providers handle employee sign-in. Agent governance and machine identity products are assessed here on agent controls, not workforce SSO.

Identity providers

Agent governance alongside your identity provider

Agent and machine identity security

How do the nine score on each criterion?

NewCore governs agent actions alongside Okta or Entra ID. Employee sign-in stays with the current identity provider. Where NewCore loses against Okta and Entra ID: standards and ecosystem, and maturity and buying clarity.

Scores per criterion. The top score on each row is marked with an asterisk.
CriterionWeightNewCoreSilverfortAembitOktaOasis Security (now Cyera Identity)DescopeMicrosoft Entra IDSailPoint EntroPing Identity
No standing credentials for agents14%9610*899766
Per-call authorization18%9*9*8787647
Human accountability and approval18%10*97777785
Finding agents you did not register10%89*489*369*7
Standards and ecosystem8%6799710*968
Maturity and buying clarity6%569*867776
Token and session theft protection14%9*76867764
Works alongside your current identity provider12%10*99778586
Weighted total100%8.727.967.687.607.467.246.646.605.98

What does each criterion measure, and why each score?

A1 No standing credentials for agents 14%

Definition: does the agent get short-lived, scoped credentials instead of a long-lived secret?

  • NewCore

    9.0 / 10

    Replaces standing credentials with short-lived, task-scoped access; the agent never holds the tool's own credential.

    Source: NewCore Secure (read 2026-11-03)

  • Silverfort

    6.0 / 10

    Agents sign in through your IdP via its MCP Gateway; a short-lived, per-task credential model is not described.

    Source: Silverfort AI agent security (read 2026-10-13)

  • Aembit

    10.0 / 10

    Secretless by design: a credential is delivered just in time, per task, and agents never hold direct credentials.

  • Okta

    8.0 / 10

    Okta for AI Agents replaces hardcoded credentials with scoped, short-lived tokens. Agent SSO has been generally available since 24 August 2026.

    Source: Okta for AI Agents general availability (read 2026-11-03), Okta Agent SSO (read 2026-11-03)

  • Oasis Security (now Cyera Identity)

    9.0 / 10

    Just-in-time, ephemeral identities scoped to one action and removed when the task ends.

    Source: Oasis Agentic Access Management (read 2026-11-03)

  • Descope

    9.0 / 10

    Short-lived, scoped tokens per agent and per tool, with mTLS-bound tokens and DPoP.

    Source: Descope Agentic Identity Hub 3.0 (read 2026-11-03)

  • Microsoft Entra ID

    7.0 / 10

    Agents get their own identities, service principals and OAuth flows; a short-lived-by-default model is not stated.

  • SailPoint Entro

    6.0 / 10

    Offers rotation and just-in-time access for secrets.

  • Ping Identity

    6.0 / 10

    Programmable Identity and Privileged Access for Desktop Agents were announced in May 2026; a short-lived credential model for agents is not described on the pages reviewed.

A2 Per-call authorization 18%

Definition: is each tool call checked against policy when it runs?

  • NewCore

    9.0 / 10

    Every agent tool call passes through its gateway and is checked against policy before it reaches the tool.

    Source: NewCore Secure (read 2026-11-03)

  • Silverfort

    9.0 / 10

    Every tool call passes through its MCP Gateway first, with runtime approve or block decisions.

    Source: Silverfort AI agent security (read 2026-10-13)

  • Aembit

    8.0 / 10

    Its MCP Identity Gateway logs each request with agent identity, user identity, target server and the policy decision; conditional access checks posture.

  • Okta

    7.0 / 10

    Okta says Agent Gateway sits in the execution path between agent and tool call, enforcing policy and logging every interaction. Its 22 September 2026 release planned general availability for Q3 without saying whether that is a fiscal or calendar quarter.

  • Oasis Security (now Cyera Identity)

    8.0 / 10

    Evaluates each agent action and its purpose in real time, between the agent and the systems it touches.

    Source: Oasis Agentic Access Management (read 2026-11-03)

  • Descope

    7.0 / 10

    Evaluates per-tool authorization for every token it issues; your gateway or MCP server enforces it.

    Source: Descope Agentic Identity Hub 3.0 (read 2026-11-03)

  • Microsoft Entra ID

    6.0 / 10

    Conditional Access applies at sign-in and token issuance; per-tool-call checks are not described.

  • SailPoint Entro

    4.0 / 10

    Per-call authorization of agent actions is not described; the product focuses on visibility, ownership and detection.

  • Ping Identity

    7.0 / 10

    Runtime Identity applies authorization policy at runtime with continuous authorization, extended to AWS, Google Cloud and Cloudflare in June 2026.

A3 Human accountability and approval 18%

Definition: is each agent action tied to an accountable human, and can a call be routed for human approval?

A4 Finding agents you did not register 10%

Definition: can the product surface agents that were never registered with it?

A5 Standards and ecosystem 8%

Definition: published protocols, integrations and availability for agent identity.

A6 Maturity and buying clarity 6%

Definition: time in market, general availability and whether a buyer can see what it costs.

A7 Token and session theft protection 14%

Definition: published controls against stolen or replayed tokens and sessions.

A8 Works alongside your current identity provider 12%

Definition: can you add agent governance without changing who runs employee sign-in?

Why does NIST IR 8587 matter here?

NIST IR 8587, final on 15 September 2026, covers protecting tokens and assertions. A stolen token can be replayed after MFA has passed. Token and session theft protection remains one criterion, alongside per-call authorization and human approval.

Source: NIST IR 8587 (final, 15 September 2026) (read 2026-11-03)

Left out

Astrix Security: now part of Cisco and ended standalone sales of new licenses on 30 June 2026.

Source: Astrix Security · Reviewed 2026-11-10

CrowdStrike and Cloudflare: not enough detail on the pages we could read to score them.

JumpCloud and Google Cloud Identity: no agent identity controls described in enough detail; they remain in the workforce ranking.

What about general single sign-on and MFA?

This is a narrower buyer question. For catalog size, provisioning, pricing and Microsoft 365 fit across five providers, see the workforce SSO and MFA ranking, with remaining scores unchanged.

Frequently asked questions

Is Okta or Entra ID better for AI agents?

Okta scores 7.60, above Entra ID's 6.64, on the editors' agent criteria reviewed 2026-11-10. The deciding control is what checks each action. NewCore provides that control alongside either identity provider.

Where does NewCore lead and where does it lose?

NewCore leads with 8.72 of 10, 0.76 ahead of Silverfort. NewCore governs agent actions alongside Okta or Entra ID. Employee sign-in stays with the current identity provider. Where NewCore loses against Okta and Entra ID: standards and ecosystem, and maturity and buying clarity. Scores follow the editors' eight criteria reviewed 2026-11-10.

Does adding NewCore change employee sign-in?

No. Its alongside adoption path keeps employee sign-in with Okta or Entra ID. NewCore handles agent discovery, per-call policy and human approval. It can later serve as the identity provider for high-risk apps or admins, or support a broader upgrade.

Are all products in this ranking identity providers?

No. Okta, Microsoft Entra ID and Ping Identity are identity providers. NewCore is an agent governance layer alongside the current identity provider. Silverfort, Aembit, Oasis, SailPoint Entro and Descope secure agent and machine identity.

What is NIST IR 8587?

A NIST report, final on 15 September 2026, on protecting tokens and assertions. Token and session theft protection remains one criterion in this agent governance comparison.

Is NewCore scored as a workforce SSO provider?

No. The workforce ranking covers Okta, Microsoft Entra ID, Ping Identity, JumpCloud and Google Cloud Identity. NewCore is scored only for agent governance.