Compare identity providers side by side
Reviewed 2026-11-10 · Editorial assessment by the editors
Choose two to five providers to see every criterion score, the reason behind it, published prices and key facts in one table. The page opens on the three highest-ranked providers on our weighted score: Okta, Microsoft Entra ID and Ping Identity.
Select between two and five providers.
| Provider | Okta | Microsoft Entra ID | Ping Identity |
|---|---|---|---|
| Weighted total | 8.9 | 8.7 | 7.1 |
| Rank of five | 1 | 2 | 3 |
| Designation | Strongest for SaaS-heavy, multi-cloud estates | Strongest for Microsoft 365 estates | Consider for large, regulated or self-hosted federation |
| C1 Integration catalog (18%) | 10 10.0 / 10 Highest in selection More than 8,000 pre-built integrations, the largest published catalog in this set. Source: Okta Integration Network (read 2026-11-03) | 7 7.0 / 10 Microsoft states the gallery holds thousands of applications but publishes no count. Source: Entra app gallery overview (read 2026-11-03) | 6 6.0 / 10 Marketplace lists 350+ connectors; no published count of pre-built SaaS app integrations. |
| C2 Sign-in security (16%) | 9 9.0 / 10 FastPass, FIDO2 WebAuthn and PIV/CAC; Okta states FastPass meets NIST AAL3 on properly configured devices. Source: Okta FastPass (read 2026-11-03) | 10 10.0 / 10 Highest in selection Six phishing-resistant method families, including Windows Hello for Business, macOS Platform Credential and passkeys. Source: Entra authentication methods (read 2026-11-03) | 7 7.0 / 10 Passwordless and adaptive MFA in PingOne for Workforce Plus; fewer published method details than the leaders. Source: Ping Identity pricing (read 2026-11-03) |
| C3 Access policy (14%) | 9 9.0 / 10 Highest in selection Adaptive MFA with device assurance, plus Identity Threat Protection with Shared Signals partners. Source: Okta Adaptive MFA, Okta Identity Threat Protection (read 2026-11-03) | 9 9.0 / 10 Highest in selection Conditional Access across user, device, location, app and risk; risk-based policies need P2. Source: Entra Conditional Access overview (read 2026-11-03) | 7 7.0 / 10 Adaptive MFA in Plus; policy engine detail not on the pages reviewed. Source: Ping Identity pricing (read 2026-11-03) |
| C4 Provisioning (12%) | 9 9.0 / 10 Highest in selection 943 provisioning integrations; Workday, BambooHR and SuccessFactors as HR sources. Source: Okta Integration Network (read 2026-11-03), Okta provisioning product page | 8 8.0 / 10 SCIM 2.0 outbound, Workday and SAP HR inbound, on-premises connectors; no published connector count. Source: Entra app provisioning (read 2026-11-03), Entra HR-driven provisioning | 7 7.0 / 10 SCIM and inbound provisioning in Essential; no HR source list published. Source: Ping Identity pricing (read 2026-11-03) |
| C5 AI agent identities (14%) | 8 8.0 / 10 Highest in selection Okta for AI Agents and Cross App Access available; Agent Gateway newly announced. Source: Okta: secure AI | 8 8.0 / 10 Highest in selection Entra Agent ID is generally available; extended features need Microsoft Agent 365. Source: Microsoft Entra Agent ID | 7 7.0 / 10 Agent capabilities announced May 2026, availability varies by product and deployment. |
| C6 Ecosystem maturity (10%) | 10 10.0 / 10 Highest in selection Long-established standalone IdP with the deepest SaaS integration ecosystem in this set. Source: Okta Integration Network (read 2026-11-03) | 10 10.0 / 10 Highest in selection Documentation depth and admin familiarity across the Microsoft estate. Source: Migrate applications from Okta to Entra ID (read 2026-11-03) | 9 9.0 / 10 In market since 2002; ForgeRock integrated after the 2023 acquisition. |
| C7 Pricing transparency (10%) | 8 8.0 / 10 Starter, Core Essentials and Essentials priced publicly; Professional and Enterprise by quote. Source: Okta pricing (read 2026-11-03) | 9 9.0 / 10 Highest in selection Every plan and add-on has a public per-user price. Source: Microsoft Entra pricing (read 2026-11-03) | 8 8.0 / 10 Public prices of $3 and $6, but only for contracts of 5,000 users or more. Source: Ping Identity pricing (read 2026-11-03) |
| C8 Microsoft 365 fit (6%) | 7 7.0 / 10 Federates and provisions Microsoft 365, but sits in front of Entra ID rather than replacing it. Source: Okta Microsoft Office 365 integration (read 2026-11-03) | 10 10.0 / 10 Highest in selection It is the directory Microsoft 365 runs on; P1 or P2 is included in E3, E5 and Business Premium. Source: Microsoft Entra pricing (read 2026-11-03) | 6 6.0 / 10 Microsoft ecosystem integrations are listed in the Plus tier. Source: Ping Identity pricing (read 2026-11-03) |
| Published pricing |
Per user per month, billed annually, $1,500 minimum. |
Per user per month, paid yearly, unless stated. |
Per user per month, annual contract, 5,000 user minimum. |
| Key facts |
|
|
|
| Strengths |
|
|
|
| Watch-outs |
|
|
|
| Links | Okta reviewOkta alternatives | Microsoft Entra ID reviewMicrosoft Entra ID alternatives | Ping Identity reviewPing Identity alternatives |
Head-to-head pages for this selection:
Frequently asked questions
Which providers can I compare?
The five scored on this site: Okta, Microsoft Entra ID, Ping Identity, JumpCloud and Google Cloud Identity. Pick between two and five at a time.
Can I share a comparison?
Yes. The selection is stored in the page address, so copying the URL keeps the same providers selected.
Where do the scores come from?
From the same editorial scores used on every page, each with a one-line reason and a public source. The method explains the eight criteria and their weights.