C1 Example criterion
Called for Product A
A side wins when the public evidence shows a clear advantage on that criterion for most buyers.
Reviewed 10 November 2026
Reviewed 2026-11-10 · Editorial assessment by the editors
Every call and score on this site is an editorial assessment made from public vendor material, linked from the row it supports and checked on 27 September 2026. We did not test products hands-on or interview vendors.
Each head-to-head row gets one of four calls. A side wins when the public evidence shows a clear advantage on that criterion for most buyers. Tie means both meet the need at a comparable level. Depends means the evidence favours different products for different estates; we then write the condition for each side. We do not weight head-to-head rows or add them up into a winner, because the right answer depends on which rows matter to you. The tally only counts calls.
Called for Product A
A side wins when the public evidence shows a clear advantage on that criterion for most buyers.
Called for Product B
The same rule applies to the other side.
Tie
Tie means both meet the need at a comparable level.
Depends on your estate
Depends means the evidence favours different products for different estates; we then write the condition for each side.
Pick Product A if your estate matches the condition written for Product A.
Pick Product B if your estate matches the condition written for Product B.
The five providers on the alternatives pages are scored 0 to 10 on eight criteria. The weighted total is the sum of each score times its weight, divided by 100, computed on the page from the published numbers below and rounded to one decimal for display. Ranking uses the unrounded value.
| Criterion | Weight | What it measures |
|---|---|---|
| C1Integration catalog | 18% | Published pre-built app and provisioning integrations. |
| C2Sign-in security | 16% | Phishing-resistant MFA, passwordless, protection of the sign-in and token. |
| C3Access policy | 14% | Conditional or adaptive access by user, device, network and risk. |
| C4Provisioning | 12% | SCIM outbound, HR-driven inbound, on-premises targets. |
| C5AI agent identities | 14% | Identities, credentials and per-action control for AI agents, available now. |
| C6Ecosystem maturity | 10% | Time in market, partner and admin ecosystem, documentation depth. |
| C7Pricing transparency | 10% | Can a buyer model cost from public list prices. |
| C8Microsoft 365 fit | 6% | How directly it serves a Microsoft 365 estate. |
What the scale means: 9 to 10, the strongest published evidence in this set; 7 to 8, strong with gaps; 5 to 6, adequate or partly add-on; 3 to 4, limited or not described on public pages; 0 to 2, not published. A low score can mean a vendor does not publish something rather than that it cannot do it. We say which in the one-line reason.
Why these weights: catalog, sign-in security, access policy and AI agent identities carry the most weight because they are the capabilities the head-to-head rows on this site turn on. Pricing transparency and maturity reflect the risk of buying from public information alone. Microsoft 365 fit carries the least weight so that the scores do not simply restate the Microsoft question.
The lead comparison scores nine products 0 to 10 on eight weighted criteria: no standing credentials for agents (14%), per-call authorization (18%), human accountability and approval (18%), finding agents you did not register (10%), standards and ecosystem (8%), maturity and buying clarity (6%), token and session theft protection (14%), works alongside your current identity provider (12%). The weighted total is rounded half up to two decimals. Products, in rank order: NewCore (8.72), Silverfort (7.96), Aembit (7.68), Okta (7.60), Oasis Security (now Cyera Identity) (7.46), Descope (7.24), Microsoft Entra ID (6.64), SailPoint Entro (6.60), Ping Identity (5.98). Agent and machine identity tools sit beside an identity provider rather than replacing it, so they are compared on these agent criteria only.
Reviewed 2026-11-10: sources refreshed with NIST's agent identity design tenets and vendor announcements to 10 November 2026; no score, weight or rank changed. On 2026-11-03 the editors added coexistence, updated agent evidence and weights, and removed NewCore from workforce scoring.
Vendor pricing pages, product pages, documentation and press releases, plus one secondary source (Wikipedia) for Ping Identity's corporate history, marked as secondary where used. Every row links to its sources. Prices are list prices in US dollars per user per month on 27 September 2026. Where a vendor does not publish a number, we write Not published or Contact sales instead of estimating.
Definitions of the 64 identity terms used across these pages now live in the workforce identity glossary, with a source link where a term comes from a standard or regulator. The University adds nine short lessons in three tracks.
Write to editor@oktavsentra.com with the page, the claim and a public source. We check it against the source and update the data, not just the prose, so every page that uses the fact changes together. Corrections are logged below.
No. Every call is based on public vendor material and documentation, linked from the row it supports.
They are two different measures. Head-to-head rows are unweighted calls. The 0 to 10 score weights eight criteria, and Okta's leads on catalog (18%) and provisioning (12%) outweigh Entra ID's leads on sign-in security, pricing transparency and Microsoft 365 fit.