C1 Integration catalog
Tie
Google Cloud Identity 6/10: Thousands of pre-integrated SAML and OIDC apps; no exact count. Ping Identity 6/10: Marketplace lists 350+ connectors; no published count of pre-built SaaS app integrations.
Reviewed 10 November 2026
Reviewed 2026-09-29
Ping Identity scores higher overall on our weighted criteria, 7.1 against 6.0 out of 10. Google Cloud Identity does not score higher on any of the eight criteria; Ping Identity scores higher on provisioning, AI agent identities, ecosystem maturity and Microsoft 365 fit. They tie on integration catalog, sign-in security, access policy and pricing transparency.
4 ties · 0 depends · 8 criteria
Tie
Google Cloud Identity 6/10: Thousands of pre-integrated SAML and OIDC apps; no exact count. Ping Identity 6/10: Marketplace lists 350+ connectors; no published count of pre-built SaaS app integrations.
Tie
Google Cloud Identity 7/10: Passkeys and Titan Security Keys supported. Ping Identity 7/10: Passwordless and adaptive MFA in PingOne for Workforce Plus; fewer published method details than the leaders.
Tie
Google Cloud Identity 7/10: Context-Aware Access, Premium edition only. Ping Identity 7/10: Adaptive MFA in Plus; policy engine detail not on the pages reviewed.
Called for Ping Identity
Google Cloud Identity 5/10: Automated provisioning to third-party apps is Premium only; no HR inbound source listed. Ping Identity 7/10: SCIM and inbound provisioning in Essential; no HR source list published.
Called for Ping Identity
Google Cloud Identity 3/10: No AI agent identity product on the pages reviewed. Ping Identity 7/10: Agent capabilities announced May 2026, availability varies by product and deployment.
Called for Ping Identity
Google Cloud Identity 8/10: Mature as the identity layer for Google Workspace and Google Cloud. Ping Identity 9/10: In market since 2002; ForgeRock integrated after the 2023 acquisition.
Tie
Google Cloud Identity 8/10: $7.2 per user per month published; Free edition available. Ping Identity 8/10: Public prices of $3 and $6, but only for contracts of 5,000 users or more.
Called for Ping Identity
Google Cloud Identity 3/10: Built for Google estates; Microsoft 365 is a SAML app to it. Ping Identity 6/10: Microsoft ecosystem integrations are listed in the Plus tier.
| Criterion | Weight | Google Cloud Identity | Ping Identity | Higher score |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| C1 Integration catalog | 18% | 6 | 6 | Tie |
| C2 Sign-in security | 16% | 7 | 7 | Tie |
| C3 Access policy | 14% | 7 | 7 | Tie |
| C4 Provisioning | 12% | 5 | 7 | Ping Identity |
| C5 AI agent identities | 14% | 3 | 7 | Ping Identity |
| C6 Ecosystem maturity | 10% | 8 | 9 | Ping Identity |
| C7 Pricing transparency | 10% | 8 | 8 | Tie |
| C8 Microsoft 365 fit | 6% | 3 | 6 | Ping Identity |
| Weighted total | 100% | 6.0 | 7.1 | Ping Identity |
| Plan | Price | What it includes |
|---|---|---|
| Cloud Identity Free | $0 | User cap increase of 50 per Google's documentation |
| Cloud Identity Premium | $7.2 per user per month |
Source: Cloud Identity editions (read 2026-11-03), Google Cloud Identity
List prices from Google.
| Plan | Price | What it includes |
|---|---|---|
| PingOne for Workforce Essential | $3 | |
| PingOne for Workforce Plus | $6 |
Source: Ping Identity pricing (read 2026-11-03)
Per user per month, annual contract, 5,000 user minimum.
Choose Google Cloud Identity if Google Workspace is your primary suite and most of your apps are SAML or OpenID Connect apps.
Choose Ping Identity if you have 5,000 users or more, or you must run federation yourself in containers or in a FedRAMP High environment.
Google Cloud Identity's highest scores are Ecosystem maturity (8) and Pricing transparency (8). Ping Identity's are Ecosystem maturity (9) and Pricing transparency (8).
Ping Identity scores higher overall on our weighted criteria, 7.1 against 6.0 out of 10. The weighted total uses our eight published criterion weights; see the method.
Google Cloud Identity: Cloud Identity Free $0; Cloud Identity Premium $7.2 per user per month. List prices from Google. Ping Identity: PingOne for Workforce Essential $3; PingOne for Workforce Plus $6. Per user per month, annual contract, 5,000 user minimum.
Ping Identity scores higher on provisioning, AI agent identities, ecosystem maturity and Microsoft 365 fit.
Read dates are recorded beside each source.