Okta vs Entra ID: seven common assumptions checked against published facts
Reviewed 2026-11-10 · Editorial assessment by the editors
By the editors · Published 2026-09-24 · 3 min read
Several shortcuts buyers use to compare Okta and Entra ID do not survive a read of the vendors' own pages. Entra ID Free already covers SSO across SaaS apps, Okta sits in front of Entra ID rather than removing it, and Okta's entry price is lower than Entra ID P1. Both now sell AI agent identity products.
Why check the assumptions?
Okta and Microsoft Entra ID are compared so often that the comparison has picked up folklore. Some of it was true years ago, some was never quite right, and some depends on which licence you already hold. Each point below is set against what the vendor publishes, with the source listed at the end of the note.
Assumption 1: Entra ID only works for Microsoft apps
Not so. Entra ID Free lists unlimited SSO across SaaS apps, and Microsoft describes its app gallery as containing thousands of applications, with SAML, OpenID Connect, password-based and linked SSO. What is true is that Entra ID's strongest features assume Microsoft devices, security tools and licences, and that Okta publishes the larger catalog: more than 8,000 pre-built integrations against Microsoft's unnumbered thousands.
Assumption 2: Okta can take Microsoft 365 off Entra ID
It cannot. Okta's Microsoft Office 365 integration federates Microsoft 365 sign-in to Okta and provisions users, groups and attributes, but Entra ID stays underneath as the directory Microsoft 365 runs on. Running Okta for Microsoft 365 means two identity layers, two licences and two policy sets. That can be the right choice; it is never a removal of Entra ID.
Assumption 3: Okta always costs more
At the entry tier it costs less: Okta Starter is $6 per user per month against $7.00 for Entra ID P1. The picture changes with features. Okta's Adaptive MFA starts at Core Essentials, $14, while P1 at $7.00 includes Conditional Access and is already part of Microsoft 365 E3 and Business Premium. Okta also has a $1,500 minimum contract. The pricing comparison matches the tiers.
Assumption 4: moving off Okta is one big cutover
Microsoft documents the opposite. Its tutorials split the move into application inventory, SAML and OpenID Connect apps, custom authorization servers, Microsoft 365 federation, sync provisioning and sign-on policies, and staged rollout lets pilot groups sign in with cloud authentication before the domain is converted. Okta can keep federating Microsoft 365 while apps move one at a time. See federated and managed domains.
Assumption 5: Azure AD and Entra ID are different products
They are the same service. Microsoft renamed Azure Active Directory to Microsoft Entra ID, with the new name in use from 15 August 2023. Older documentation and job titles still use the old name.
Assumption 6: a bigger catalog means all your apps are covered
Okta's catalog is the largest published in this comparison, and it counts for 18 percent of our weighted score. But a catalog helps only for the apps in it. Build an inventory first and mark each app as catalog SSO, catalog with provisioning, custom SAML or OpenID Connect, or passwords only. The lesson on app catalogs walks through it.
Assumption 7: neither has an answer for AI agents
Both do now, and both product lines are young. Microsoft lists Entra Agent ID as generally available to all Entra customers, with extended security features under a Microsoft Agent 365 licence. Okta lists Okta for AI Agents and Cross App Access, and on 22 September 2026 said Agent SSO, which issues short-lived tokens to agents, is generally available. NewCore adds agent governance alongside existing identity providers. The AI agents comparison calls the two large vendors.
So which is better?
Neither across the board. On our ten ballot criteria Okta wins two, Entra ID wins three, two are ties and three depend on your estate; on the eight weighted criteria Okta scores 8.9 and Entra ID 8.7 out of 10. Entra ID is the better default for Microsoft 365 organisations and Okta the better fit for mixed, SaaS-heavy estates. Read the verdict.