Conditional access and adaptive MFA explained: how sign-in policy decides
Reviewed 2026-11-10 · Editorial assessment by the editors
By the editors · 3 min read
Sign-in policy is the set of if-then rules an identity provider runs before it lets someone in: who the user is, which device and network they are on, which app they want and how risky the attempt looks. In Entra ID the engine is Conditional Access, which needs P1. In Okta it is Adaptive MFA and device assurance, from Core Essentials.
What does a sign-in policy do?
Authentication proves who someone is. Policy decides what happens next: allow, block, or allow only after an extra step such as a phishing-resistant factor or a compliant device. A policy might say that finance staff opening the payroll app from an unmanaged laptop must use a passkey, or that sign-ins from an unfamiliar country are blocked. The rules run on every sign-in, and on some platforms during the session as well.
Which signals do the engines use?
Microsoft describes Conditional Access as its Zero Trust policy engine. It evaluates the user, group or agent, the IP location, the device, the application and real-time risk, and can hand sessions to Microsoft Defender for Cloud Apps for further control.
Okta's Adaptive MFA uses context from devices, networks, locations, behaviour and IP addresses, detects impossible travel and runs device assurance posture checks. Identity Threat Protection extends this after sign-in with continuous risk evaluation, Universal Logout, and signals from CrowdStrike, Zscaler, Palo Alto Networks and Jamf over the Shared Signals Framework.
Which licence do you need?
- Entra ID: security defaults are free to all customers; Conditional Access needs P1 ($7.00 per user per month); risk-based policies need P2 ($10.00). P1 is included in Microsoft 365 E3 and Business Premium, P2 in E5.
- Okta: Adaptive MFA starts at Core Essentials, $14 per user per month, billed annually; Identity Threat Protection is listed in Professional, priced by quote.
- Ping Identity: adaptive MFA is in PingOne for Workforce Plus, $6 per user per month on contracts of 5,000 users or more.
- Google Cloud Identity: Context-Aware Access is a Premium feature.
- JumpCloud: conditional access is sold as an add-on.
Can the policy come from one provider and the factor from another?
Increasingly, yes. Microsoft lists External MFA as generally available in February 2026: Entra ID keeps enforcing the policy while another provider handles the factor. Okta takes signals from other security vendors into its decisions. Standards such as the Shared Signals Framework and CAEP let one system tell another that a session's risk has changed, and the OpenID Foundation says NIST IR 8587 recommends both.
Where does this matter on this site?
The conditional access comparison calls Okta and Entra ID row by row, and the verdict marks the policy criterion as depends: the stronger engine is the one fed by the security tools you already run.